Summary
A gun expert explains whyDirty Harryis the most accurate depiction of a .44 Magnum. Starring Clint Eastwood as the eponymous police inspector Harry Callahan,Dirty Harryis a 1971 crime drama about Harry’s struggle to capture a psychopathic killer who is referred to as “the Scorpio Killer.“Dirty Harrywas directed by Don Siegel and featured aleading cast including Eastwood, Andrew Robinson, Harry Guardino, Reni Santoni, John Vernon, John Larch, John Mitchum, and Mae Mercer.
Speaking withCorridor Crew, gun expert Taran Butler praises the depiction of a .44 Magnum inDirty Harry.
According to Butler, the main thing that setDirty Harryapart from other movies that used .44 Magnum guns wasthe fact that Eastwood “faked the recoil.“Butler attributed this specificity to the fact that Eastwood himself had ample experience shooting guns. He compared theDirty Harryscene to Arnold Schwarzenegger’sRed Heat, and how that movie was inspired by the greatness ofDirty Harry. Check out Butler’s quote below:
What Clint Eastwood did great is he faked the recoil. He had the gun go up, because he really shot guns. If he didn’t do that, the 44 mag would seem like it had no power.
How Was Dirty Harry Received?
Dirty Harry Did Well Critically And Commercially
Dirty Harrywas a seminal work in its genre during the time of its release, and it succeeded commercially and critically. At the box office, the film made $35.9 million, which was an exorbitant total against its $4 million budget.It was so successful that it was followed up by four sequels, including 1973’sMagnum Force, 1976’sThe Enforcer, 1983’sSudden Impact, and 1988’sThe Dead Pool. While none of the sequels possessed the same originality asDirty Harry, the film nonetheless set a precedent for those who came after it within the genre.
In addition to its commercial success,Dirty Harryalso succeeded in the eyes of critics.Today, the film boasts an 89% score on Rotten Tomatoes across the 55 critics who have reviewed it over time. The over 50,000 audience members who rated the film gave it a 90% approval rating, exhibiting the widespread and enduring love ofDirty Harry.
How Guns Were Central To Clint Eastwood’s Film Roles
The Actor Got His Start In Westerns
It is interesting that Butler points out Eastwood’s knowledge of guns as critical toDirty Harry’s success, as the film was released during a time whenthe actor was closely associated with the gunslinger. Before the 1971 film,Eastwood had spent over a decade working in Westerns, where he often wielded a gun. This included theFistful of Dollarstrilogy, which consisted of the filmsA Fistful of Dollars,A Few Dollars More, andThe Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. Eastwood’s other Westerns includedHang ‘Em High,Coogan’s Buff, and the TV seriesRawhide.
Clint Eastwood’s 15 Best Movies, Ranked
Clint Eastwood is one of Hollywood’s most iconic filmmakers and movie stars. In nearly 70 years of working on films, here are his best.
Even as Eastwood continued his career with more mature roles,guns were an important part of his on-screen characters. In his 1992 Oscar-winnerUnforgiven, for example, Eastwood played a retired gunslinger named William Munny, paying homage to the characters that had typified his early career. Even movies likeGran Torino, wherein the actor plays a Korean War veteran, saw guns as a central feature in some ways. Tracing this element of Eastwood’s career further contextualizes why his gun work was so strong inDirty Harry.
Eastwood’s gunslinging movies are iconic enough to hold up today in conversations about the genre.His spaghetti Westerns have particularly held up, as it was announced earlier this month thatA Fistful of Dollarswould be getting a remake. As this film gets made and dabbles in its gun usage (albeit with different weapons), it will be interesting to see how the reproduced version of Eastwood’s work holds up in accuracy to great films likeDirty Harry.
TheFistfull of Dollarsremake does not yet have a cast, or a director.
Clint Eastwood’s Most Critically Recognized Films Are Not Just His Westerns
But The Western Genre Was Critical In His Career
While Westerns and spaghetti Westerns were vital to Eastwood’s career, his gun-touting works are not what has earned him the most critical recognition in his oeuvre. In his career,Eastwood has won four Oscars, the first two of which were in 1993, forUnforgiven.Unforgivenearned him awards for Best Picture and Best Director, and a nod for Best Actor. WhileUnforgivenchallenges the Western genre by making its protagonist a retired gunslinger, it is the closest to the genre among Eastwood’s Oscar-nominated works.
Eastwood’s other two Oscar wins came from the boxing dramaMillion Dollar Babyin 2005, for which, likeUnforgiven, he won Best Director and Best Picture. In conversations about Eastwood’s work,Million Dollar Babyis often regarded as one of or even the best works by the producer-director.He was also nominated for an award for Best Actor forMillion Dollar Baby. After these nominations, he went on to be nominated for three more Oscars for non-Westerns, includingLetters from Iwo JimaandAmerican Sniper.
Clint Eastwood lost hisUnforgivenandMillion Dollar Babyacting Oscars to Al Pacino inScent of a Womanand Jamie Foxx inRay,respectively.
This dissociation between the genres of Eastwood’s early career — which was founded in the Western, and the gun-laden thriller — and those that get awards recognition is fascinating to explore.This is not to say that Eastwood’s early work is of any lesser quality, as noir-style works likeDirty Harryarguably rival the quality of something likeMillion Dollar Baby. The thriller and spaghetti Western genre films are often a tougher sell to Oscar voters in the moment, but eventually prove to be crucial pieces of film history and, in this case, of Eastwood’s career.
Dirty Harryis not a Western either, by any means, but it does see Eastwood in an era of genre films. Itfits the archetype of a neo-noir thriller, though, and as is clear from the Corridor Crew video,guns are as central to the aesthetics of the movie as they are to any of Eastwood’s Western works.Dirty Harryis not the film that earned him the greatest award recognition, but it will remain a model of what makes Eastwood’s career great.
Dirty Harry
Cast
Clint Eastwood stars in the western Dirty Harry as a no-nonsense San Francisco cop who takes the law into his own hands in pursuit of a serial killer, Scorpio. Directed by Don Siegel and featuring a memorable score by Lalo Schifrin, the film is known for its iconic catchphrases and intense action scenes, and has influenced countless films and TV shows in the years since its release.
